TIG Welding
Microstructure: The weld center line may have chromium carbide precipitation, and the heat-affected zone (HAZ) may form martensite due to rapid cooling, resulting in a relatively large hardness difference between the weld and the base metal.
Mechanical Properties: It can obtain higher tensile strength, with the ultimate tensile strength (UTS) reaching about 526 MPa, but the yield strength is relatively low, about 300 MPa.
Residual Stress: The residual stress is relatively high. In the HAZ and base metal areas, the residual stress reaches the maximum within 5 mm from the weld toe, and then gradually decreases.
Advantages and Disadvantages: The weld has good forming quality and high precision, suitable for thin plates and precision welding. However, the welding efficiency is low, and the heat input is relatively large, resulting in a wider HAZ.
MAG Welding
Microstructure: The weld metal is mainly composed of acicular ferrite, bainite, and a small amount of pearlite, presenting columnar crystals and a small amount of equiaxed crystals.
Mechanical Properties: The joint tensile strength can be greater than the lower limit of the base metal strength, and the fracture position is usually in the base metal. The bending performance is good, and there are no cracks on the tension surface when the bending angle is 180°.
Residual Stress: The residual stress distribution is relatively complex. After reaching the maximum value, it first decreases and then increases, which is related to the welding process parameters and cooling rate.
Advantages and Disadvantages: It has high welding efficiency, large penetration depth, and is suitable for welding medium-thick plates. The joint organization is relatively uniform, but the strength is slightly lower than that of manual arc welding and submerged arc welding.
High-frequency Pulse MAG Welding
Microstructure: Compared with conventional pulse MAG welding, it can obtain more ideal joint organization, with more acicular ferrite in the weld, and no lath ferrite in the weld and fusion zone. The grain coarsening degree in the overheated zone is smaller.
Mechanical Properties: The low-temperature (-40°C) impact toughness is better, and the impact energy of the weld zone is about 9.6% higher than that of conventional pulse MAG welding. The welding heat input is relatively small, which is beneficial to improving the comprehensive mechanical properties of the joint.
Advantages and Disadvantages: It has strong root penetration ability, can increase the width of the root weld, and has better joint performance. However, the equipment cost is relatively high, and the process parameters need to be precisely adjusted.
Submerged Arc Welding (SAW)
Microstructure: The joint organization has uniform particles and regular morphology, with a relatively high ferrite content and a relatively low pearlite content.
Mechanical Properties: It can ensure the weld quality, and the strength is relatively high, suitable for welding thick plates. The multi-wire submerged arc welding technology can make the weld penetration depth reach more than 85% of the plate thickness.
Advantages and Disadvantages: The welding efficiency is high, the weld forming is good, and the quality is stable. It is suitable for large-scale production and thick-plate welding, but the flexibility is poor, and it is not suitable for welding workpieces with complex shapes.
Laser-MAG Hybrid Welding
Microstructure: The cross-section of the joint shows a goblet shape, and the wire accumulation and the width of the HAZ are significantly reduced compared with MAG welding. The Widmanstatten structure in the overheated zone increases slightly due to the fast cooling speed.
Mechanical Properties: There is no significant difference in tensile strength and bending property compared with MAG welding, and both meet the production standards. The hardness is higher than that of MAG welding.
Advantages and Disadvantages: It combines the advantages of laser welding and MAG welding, with high welding speed, large penetration depth, small deformation, and good joint quality. However, the equipment is complex and the cost is high.
Precision Pulse Cold Welding
Microstructure: The HAZ width is much smaller than that of conventional welding processes, which can minimize the impact on the base metal microstructure.
Residual Stress: The residual stress is relatively low, and the stress change trend is similar to that of TIG welding, but the value is lower.
Advantages and Disadvantages: The weld appearance is excellent, and the welding deformation is small, especially suitable for small-scale repair welding and applications with strict requirements for post-weld deformation. However, the work efficiency is low.



